My friend, Rabbi Chuck, answered a religious question I had by quoting the first line of a morning prayer: My God, the soul You placed within me is pure. This is a tenet of both Judaism and Islam, but runs counter to Christianity, which maintains that God gives us an unpure soul. Christians must be baptized to rid their soul of that evil. That just seems so wrong to me. Why would God want a world filled with unpure souls?
Granpappy's Thoughts
16 May 2026
23 March 2026
On Religion
I was baptized a Methodist as a baby, sang in the Episcopal children’s choir, was confirmed in the Evangelical and Reformed Church, converted to Roman Catholicism, joined a Presbyterian church, and completed the circle by joining the North Ontario United Methodist Church.
Being a Christian requires a leap of faith which I have never been able to do. Being doubtful, I assumed the name Thomas when I became a Catholic. I accept the Bible as a record of the memory and lore of people of that time, not necessarily accurate, as the writing was done after the fact, and has been translated and interpreted many times since.
I reject the doctrine of original sin and the Adam and Eve story. Without the concept of original sin there is no need for a savior, least of all for one born of a virgin. I believe in the doctrine of the “Golden Rule” and find that Christians have been the worst offenders of it over the centuries. Witness the destruction of the Mayan civilization, the Spanish Inquisition, anti-Semitism, anti-gay, etc. all in the name of Christianity.
I believe there is an unknowable
controlling the universe that some identify as “God” or “Allah” or “Father”, they
assuming that we humans were created in it’s likeness. But I believe, because he had no better idea,
man created God in his own image.
19 March 2026
More from Books
From “Here All Along” by Sarah Hurwitz:
“We
consult the news sources and engage with the social media that confirm our own
points of view, and algorithms just keep showing us more of what we like. As a result, we’re becoming narrower-minded
and more convinced of our own unimpeachable rightness.”
“This
belief that every single one of us is created in the image of God has been
cited as the defining Jewish idea, the beating heart of the entire Jewish
enterprise. And you don’t have to
believe in any kind of deity or higher power to appreciate its
implications. Drawing on an ancient
Jewish teaching, Rabbi Yitz Greenberg argues that this idea is shorthand for
the three fundamental truths, which he deems the ‘three inalienable dignities:
1.
We
are each of infinite worth – no one is expendable, and we cannot quantify the
value of any human life.
2.
We
are all fundamentally equal – no human being is any more important than any
other human being.
3.
We
are each totally unique – there is no one else like us, and no one is
interchangeable with anybody else.”
“Other
than monotheism, there is no universally accepted Jewish creed or article of
faith defining the Divine.”
“When we
stray from our tradition of questioning and wrestling, we can easily slide into
extremism, believing that we alone possess the truth and distorting the Divine
image to fit our own small purposes.
This is a most unfortunate form of idolatry.”
Some book excerpts
Books can teach us a lot, if we are willing to learn. I read a lot, and sometimes capture thoughts I find. Here's an excerpt from “Here, There, Everywhere” by William Least Heat-Moon:
18 March 2026
B Charles
B Charles
We had become good friends when he died, all too soon, but
Rabbi B Charles Herring made a lasting impression on me. He was just plain Chuck and he helped me over
a sticky point in my religious training.
I use the word ‘training’ loosely, since it has been going on over the
past 70 or so years, both in formal settings and informal. In Chuck’s case, very informal; we used email. I had been thinking about the Christian
doctrine of Original Sin. It didn’t make
sense to me that everyone was born into a state of ‘sinner’ so I asked Chuck
about it. Without giving me specifics,
he gave me the opening line of a Jewish morning prayer: My God, the soul
that You have placed within me is pure.
In other words, the Jewish religion rejects the concept of Original Sin,
and I do too. But that is the foundation
upon which Christianity is based. So my
conclusion is that I am not a Christian.
Music
I’m not a Christian (more about this later) but I like their music, whether
oratorio, hymn or gospel. I ran into
gospel by tuning into the Gaither Homecoming series on TV. Bill and Gloria composed quite a few gospel
songs, my favorite of which is “God on the Mountain” especially when sung by
Lynda Randall. To give you an idea of
the theme, here is a bit of the lyrics:
“For
the God on the mountain, is the God in the valley
When things go wrong, He'll make them right
And the God of the good times
Is still God in the bad times
The God of the day is still God in the night.”
17 March 2026
12 March 2026
08 March 2026
Moving On Up
I thought I'd try my hand at a multicolor print, so I read a few articles about the technique and watched some videos, and this is the result:
I used the reduction process. The lightest color is printed first, in this case it was yellow:





